Murder in the Garden of Enchantment

Literary Redhead

Reviewed in the United States on January 11, 2025

What a sumptuous feast the author serves up in Book 1 of a new histfic mystery series set in 1900s Constantinople. The compelling sights of the exotic setting, the food, the fashion, the culture, the gripping mystery all combine to keep you turning the pages in delight. So look forward to Book 2!
Suzi Stembridge
5.0 out of 5 stars Although reminiscent of Agatha Christie or a game of Cluedo this story is intriguingly written.
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on January 12, 2025
This who-dun-it might require the reader to hurry to the end to discover the murderer but then find they have to reread it more leisurely because the description of life in early 20th century Ottoman Turkey is so beautifully portrayed, or to read it more thoroughly from the outset to luxuriate in the detail, a more sensible option. Always known for her immaculate research Gauci excels in this novel taking you right into the heady scene of cosmopolitan Constantinople and as the novel gathers pace with a vast array of cleverly crafted characters you will be immersed in the history, the scenery, even the tastes and scents of this vibrant ancient Byzantine city.

Diane McKewin

Reviewed in Australia on 21 November 2024

Constantinople 1900: While she is still mourning her husband’s recent death, Theodosia is delighted to receive an invitation for herself and her daughter Electra to the wedding Hamid, son of Ferid Pasha. He is to marry Behice, youngest daughter of Omer Pasha therefore joining together two of the most eminent families in the city. The wedding is to take place in the Garden of Enchantment at Ferid Pasha’s elegant mansion. Within the beautiful surroundings and atmosphere of the Garden, the very last thing anything expected was murder.

With the help of her faithful manservant Abdul Agha and drawing on her last husband’s notes as a respected Judge, Theodosia finds herself in the midst of intrigue, mystery and danger. Working alongside Chief Inspector Ibrahim who has been entrusted with the investigation by the sultan, Theodosia quickly finds that all is not what it seems.

This new book by Kathryn Gauci is a very different turn to her recent very successful stories. Set in 1900 Constantinople, there is grace and beauty in Kathryn’s descriptions of the surroundings, the clothes and the food. Every page, every chapter gives a beautiful view of all of this and there is nothing I enjoy more than being able to ‘see’ what I am reading. Kathryn, you have done this so beautifully and I love everything about this new direction and this story. I look forward to more of the Madame Theodosia Mysteries.

I highly recommend this book, all of Kathryn Gauci’s books, to other readers who will love them as I do.